Log in

2022 Prop D&E Ballot Measures

22 Sep 2022 5:07 PM | Kevin Riley

Prop D&E Comparison Chart


Prop D

Affordable Homes Now (Initiative Petition)

Prop E

Affordable Housing Production Act (BOS)

Approval Times

0-150 units: 3 months 

150+ units: 6 months 

  • No BOS approval 

  • No CEQA (environmental) or discretionary (neighborhoods)

6 months 

  • BOS approval required for projects using City property or financing

  • BOS can request additional time for any reason 

  • No CEQA (environmental) or discretionary (neighborhoods)

Path 1: 

100% Affordable Building 

140% AMI max for individual units

  • $135,800

120% AMI max for building average

  • $116,400 


Approval Streamlining:

Review and approval with objective standards and ministerial actions only

120% AMI max for individual units

  • $116,400

80% AMI max for building average 

  • $77,600


Approval Streamlining:

Review and approval with objective standards and ministerial actions only

Path 2:

 Mixed-income building (10+ units)

Number of Affordable Units:

City Inclusionary Rate (currently 22%) + 15% of the inclusionary units. 

  • Example: 22% of 100 unit building = 22 affordable units, + 15% of 22 units = 25 affordable units total


+15% Affordable Units Requirements:

No


Planning Approval Expiration:

Yes, after 36-months 

Number of Affordable Units:

City Inclusionary Rate (currently 22%) + 8% of the Building's total units. 

  • Example: 22% of 100 unit building = 22 affordable units, + 8% of total units = 30 affordable units total


+8% Affordable Units Requirements:

Yes, 30% 2BR and 30% 3BR min


Planning Approval Expiration:

Yes, after 24-months 

Path 3:

Teacher Housing 

San Francisco Unified School District or City College employee


Approval Streamlining:

Review and approval with objective standards and ministerial actions only

San Francisco Unified School District or City College employee


Approval Streamlining:

Review and approval with objective standards and ministerial actions only

Affordable Housing Reports

No

Requires the Mayor to provide annual affordable housing reports in the budget

Streamlining Expansion 

BOS can amend City law to apply streamlining to additional housing types.

No

Labor

10+ units, prevailing wage required


40+ units, provide health care benefits and offer apprenticeship opportunities 

10+ units, prevailing wage require


25+ units, use a % of workers who graduated from apprenticeship (unions)


Prop D (Affordable Homes Now)

  • Pros

    • Will likely result in a significant amount of new housing 

    • Expands who can access inclusionary housing, creates a path for “missing middle” housing (housing as a human right) 

    • De-politicizes affordable housing approval (objective compliance, not discretionary)

    • Requirements for healthcare and apprenticeship benefits 

  • Cons

    • Less leverage to demand community amenities 

    • Does not require union labor 


Prop E (Affordable Housing Production Act)

  • Pros

    • Rewards projects with a significant number of affordable units with streamlining 

    • Maintains inclusionary housing access for only low income residents 

    • Demands family-sized units in inclusionary housing 

    • Maintains a percentage union labor

    • Provides a path for Supervisors to leverage community benefits 

  • Cons

    • More regulations to comply with, less projects will quality for streamlining 

    • Maintains the option for discretionary reviews, extended approval times 

    • Cannot be expanded to other housing typologies 


Summary

  • Neither ballot measure seems to have a specific or unique impact on Duboce Triangle. 

  • Vote for Prop D if: you want it to be easier to develop housing with at least some affordable units and are okay with less BOS oversight & leverage.  

  • Vote for Prop E if: you are only interested in streamlining housing with a high number of affordable units, and are okay with maintaining BOS oversight & leverage. 


Links

Address:

2261 Market Street, PMB #301, San Francisco,CA 94114

email: info@dtna.org

Phone: 628-246-2256

Instagram:

dubocetriangleneighborhood

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software